Defra - Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.

Science Search

Science and Research Projects

Return to Science Search homepage   Return to Project List

Optimising processes for the stable operation of food waste digestion - WR1208

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is normally considered to be a stable process in which the metabolic routes are moderated and directed through syntrophic reactions between different groups of microorganisms. These involve interspecies hydrogen transfer, and some of the enzyme systems that control steps within the flow of carbon to methane and other gaseous products are dependent on enzyme systems in which trace elements play an important role. There are situations where this metabolic stability is upset, however, as a result of conditions within the digester which may be strongly influenced by feedstock characteristics. One of the most common occurrences in this respect is due to a low carbon: nitrogen ratio which when the digester is fed at a normal carbon loading leads to an excess nitrogen load in the form of ammonia which has been recognised for at least 45 years as being toxic to the process (McCarty, 1964), although the levels quoted at that time are now recognised as much lower than can be tolerated in an anaerobic system.

There are numerous examples where the AD process has suffered as a result of high ammonia concentrations, for example in cattle manure, pig slurry, chicken litter, abattoir wastes and food wastes. In the case of the latter the effects of high ammonia were clearly seen in technical-scale trials using kitchen waste collected in the UK (Banks et al., 2008), and were almost certainly the cause of digester failure in a 30,000 tonne per year food waste digester operated by Valorsul SA in Lisbon, Portugal (Neiva Correia et al., 2008). The same conditions are observed in small-scale plant as the phenomenon is caused not by the size of digester but by the microbiological and biochemical processes occurring within the system. The problems are fundamentally related to the C:N ratio of the input material and food waste is in this category because of its high protein content which leads to a C:N ratio usually around 10:1. Problems are not normally encountered with food wastes from certain manufacturing processes e.g. vegetable wastes are unlikely to generate high ammonia concentrations although they may cause problems due to deficiencies in trace elements. The current research, however, is directed towards source segregated food waste collected from domestic kitchens. Compositional analysis has shown this to have a C:N ratio in the critical range, and it is known to have caused problems in digesters operating on this feedstock in a number of locations and at all scales. The problems resulting from high ammonia are known to be due to the inhibition of acetoclastic methanogens, a fact recently confirmed for mesophilic systems as well as thermophilic (Schnurer, 2008).

The second problem associated with digestion of certain substrate types is deficiencies in trace elements, the absence of which can result in metabolic blockages in the carbon flow and the irreversible accumulation of acid products causing direct toxicity and pH change. A good example of a full-scale system believed to have failed for this reason is the BTA Toronto digester which was fed on source segregated food waste: the process was eventually stabilised by addition of a cocktail of trace elements the detail of which have not been released (Climenhaga, personal communication). In the case of trace elements the effect is often delayed as digesters are often started off with seed sludges derived from municipal wastewater treatment plants or animal slurries neither of which usually suffer from metal deficiencies. This also explains why co-digestion of foodwaste with these materials may give a better and more stable result.
The objectives of the Project are:
1. To assess the metals status of stressed digestates
2. To determine whether conditions in pre-stressed digestates, as indicated by high VFA concentration and unbalanced microbial communities, can be relieved by selective addition of trace metals in batch tests
3. To determine the effects of trace metal supplementation on the stability of a food waste digester operating in semi-continuous mode at high ammonia concentrations
4. To determine the effects of trace metal supplementation on the stability of a food waste digester operating in semi-continuous mode at reduced ammonia concentrations
5. To determine the feasibility of stripping of ammonia from digestate in the gas phase under batch conditions
6. To establish the potential for ammonia removal as a sidestream process from recycled digestate
7. To determine the performance of a first stage hydrolysis reactor in conversion of the organically-bound nitrogen in food wastes into ammonia
8. To test the preferred stripping method in a pilot-scale digestion trial
Project Documents
• Final Report : Optimising Processes for the Stable Operation of Food Waste Digestion (WR1208)   (1044k)
• Executive Summary : Optimising Processes for the Stable Operation of Food Waste Digestion (WR1208) - Executive Summary   (73k)
• Technical Report : Optimising Processes for the Stable Operation of Food Waste Digestion (WR1208) - Technical Report   (2961k)
Time-Scale and Cost
From: 2009

To: 2010

Cost: £197,870
Contractor / Funded Organisations
University - Southampton
Environmental Impacts              
Environmental Protection              
Food Waste              
Policy Development              
Processing technologies for biodegradable MSW              
Processing techs for treatment /energy recovery              
Systems for Resource Recovery              
Techniques & methodolgies for waste management              
Waste Management              
Fields of Study
Waste Management